How do you form a massive black hole binary? (Part 2)

Following the recent discovery of gravitational waves from a merging black hole binary system, I've been dedicating a few posts to exploring how such a system could have formed in the first place. Last time I talked about how such massive black holes could form, and here I want to discuss how a binary black hole system could form.

Artist's impression of a binary system comprised of
two massive OB stars (Credit: Universe Today)

The answer to this question depends a lot on where the black holes formed. It's a lot easier to form a binary black hole system in a star cluster where there might be many black holes than it would be to form such a system in relative isolation.

Lets deal with the more difficult case of forming a binary black hole system in isolation first. Most massive stars (the precursors of black holes) are actually born in (and spend most of their lives in) binary systems composed of two massive stars orbiting each other. However, there are many events during a massive star's life that can disrupt the binary.

Schematic of a binary star system undergoing
common-envelope evolution
(Credit: Adrian Potter)

First, the star swells up and inflates to become a red supergiant. These are the largest types of star known, with diameters hundreds of times their original size and many thousands of times larger than our own Sun. If the red supergiant is in a binary system then it is possible that its outer atmosphere could spill over onto the secondary star, forming an envelope of material that encompasses both stars.

This process is known as common-envelope evolution, so-called because the two stars effectively share their outer envelopes (see the figure to the right). The stars in the common envelope experience a drag on their binary orbits, slowing them down and shrinking the binary system. The phase is typically quite short-lived, but can actually end with the two stars merging!

If the binary system survives the common-envelope phase it may be disrupted by the material the star has ejected during this phase. Red supergiants expel a considerable fraction of their mass through stellar winds. This weakens the binary system by taking away some of the mass holding it together, which causes the binary system to widen. If the system widens sufficiently the stars may actually separate and the binary will be no more!

Finally, the last act in the life of a massive star is a supernova explosion. Again, this expels considerable mass from the star and therefore from the binary system, which could disrupt the binary. In fact this is a commonly-considered mechanism for the disruption of binary systems composed of two massive stars.

This presents a difficult path for a massive binary system to negotiate if it is to become a black hole binary. The system must survive a potential common-envelope phase while one (or both) stars are red supergiants and it must survive the loss of considerable mass from both stars from stellar winds and supernova explosions that can weaken the binary. However, if the system negotiates these obstacles then it could form a binary black hole system just like that observed to merge by LIGO.

Next time I'll talk about a potentially much simpler way to form a massive black hole binary system, and that's in a star cluster!

The nearest site of dense star formation, the ρ Ophiuchi Molecular Cloud

A few months ago I talked about the Taurus Molecular Cloud, a prominent and well-studied site of active star formation, which also has the privilege of being the closest such region to us. It isn't the only nearby region of star formation though, and this week I want to talk about another well-studied nearby region called the ρ Ophiuchi (pronounced rho oh-fee-ook-ee) molecular cloud.

ρ Ophiuchi is not much further away than the Taurus Molecular Cloud, lying at a distance of 400 light years from us (120 parsecs), but one of its truly special features is that it is visible from both hemispheres. Due to the orbit and rotation of the Earth, astronomical objects visible from one hemisphere are often not easily seen from the other hemisphere, simply because the Earth does not spin into a position where they could be observed.

This presents a difficulty for astronomers because astronomical observatories can therefore only observe about half the sky. Telescopes and radio antennae in the Southern hemisphere can only observe the Southern sky, and vice versa (this isn't strictly true as it depends on the precise position of the observatory, but it serves as a good general rule). This can be annoying for astronomers because it means they can't always observe their targets with the ideal telescope. For example, my favourite region Cygnus OB2 is in the Northern sky, and thus I have to use telescopes in the Northern hemisphere to study it, a very disappointing situation when one considers the wonderful telescopes available in the Southern hemisphere!

ρ Ophiuchi is one of a small number of regions that straddles the Northern and Southern skies and can be observed from observatories in both hemispheres. It is therefore much easier to study ρ Ophiuchi than it is to study the northern hemisphere Taurus Molecular Cloud for example.

The ρ Ophiuchi star forming region is made up of quite a few different components, as the image below shows. The region is very close to one of the subgroups of the Scorpius-Centaurus OB association (the subgroup is known as Upper Scorpius), which leads to a number of bright stars in the area, many of which can be seen with the naked eye. Amongst these, Antares or Alpha Scorpius is one of the most impressive. The 'Alpha' designation means that it is the brightest star in the constellation of Scorpius, and is actually the 15th brightest star in the night sky. The star is a red supergiant, a very massive star coming towards the end of its life, which will one day explode as a supernova.

The Ophiuchus Clouds and surrounding area, covering 5 x 6 degrees. The image shows
both the dark clouds of Rho Ophiuchus (L1688 and L1689) and many of the nearby
naked eye stars (Antares, Alpha and Sigma Scorpius) and the nearby globular cluster M4.
(Credit: Robert Gendler / Nick Wright)

The triple star system ρ Ophiuchus, from which the star forming region gets its name, also contains a number of massive stars, slightly less massive than Antares, and not as far towards the ends of their lives, but still very bright and impressive. They'd be even brighter in the night sky if they weren't partly embedded within the molecular cloud. These stars are what astronomers refer to as B-type stars.

The young stars of ρ Ophiuchi are actually much fainter and less massive than those in the nearby OB association. They are younger as well, only about 1 million years old, making them stellar toddlers! Most of these young stars are still embedded in the molecular cloud that they formed in, so they are difficult to see in images like this, though the molecular clouds themselves can be seen as they appear as dark clouds obscuring the background starlight. The two main clouds in ρ Ophiuchi are known as L1688 and L1689, though they're both made up of many smaller clouds.

The first proper studies of ρ Ophiuchi came with the advent of infrared astronomy in the 1970s. Infrared radiation can penetrate into the dark and obscuring clouds, allowing astronomers to see the young stars forming within them. These early studies revealed hundreds of young stars deeply embedded with the molecular clouds, many still in the processes of forming and others at the end of the formation process.

The cluster of young stars that the infrared observations uncovered is larger and denser than those in the Taurus Molecular Cloud, though not as dense as some of the more massive star clusters such as the Orion Nebula Cluster. They therefore provide a nice contrast between these two other prominent regions.

The young stars of the L1688 cloud in Rho Ophiuchus, as seen in infrared light (Credit: Spitzer Space Telescope)

By studying this large population of forming stars astronomers were able to garner insight into the star formation process and study how stars appeared to change appearance as they formed. These infrared studies also revealed an important type of object known as a starless core. These are giant globules of gas, dense and massive enough to be held together by their own gravity, but without a star inside of them. Because they are gravitationally bound but not supported by any outward forces they must be in the process of collapsing to form new stars.

By studying these starless cores astronomers have been trying to understand how stars start to form, as well as how the properties of the core affects the properties of the star that forms. For example, astronomers have discovered that the distribution of masses of these cores is very similar (if slightly larger) than the distribution of masses of stars, suggesting that stars probably form directly out of these cores with a direct correlation between the mass of the core and the mass of the star that forms within it.

Rho Ophiuchus (right) and the Pipe Nebula (left) projected against
the Galactic Centre, with many of the bright stars of the Scorpius-Centaurus
OB association also visible (Credit: Maurice Toet)

Star formation in the region is thought to have started when a shock wave from the nearby Scorpius-Centaurus OB association triggered the collapse of the ambient gas clouds in the area. This may have been caused by winds that emanate from massive stars or even possibly a supernova explosion when one of the most massive stars in the OB association died. Many astronomers think that shock waves such as this are a common trigger of large star formation events in our galaxy, and there has been considerable work to trace back these triggering events to their source.

Recent far-infrared and sub-mm observations of ρ Ophiuchi have allowed astronomers to trace the molecular gas and dust that makes up the densest parts of the molecular cloud where star formation is most active. These molecular maps have revealed that the gas has a highly filamentary structure on large scales, with multiple dense clumps on the smaller scales where stars are beginning to form.

Rho Ophiuchus (right) and the Pipe Nebula (left) with a colour map
projected on top showing the density of molecular gas
(Credit: ESO, S. Guisard and J. Kainulainen)

It is thought that stellar winds and supernovae sculpt the gas in these molecular clouds into these massive filamentary structures, which then become gravitationally unstable and collapse to form the dense cores that are the precursors of forming stars. Trying to understand how these filaments of gas are created and how stars form from them is an area of very active research at the moment.

ρ Ophiuchi has proved to be not only an amazing location to study young and forming stars, but also to study all the processes that lead up to star formation: the sculpting of molecular gas, the collapse of long filaments into dense cores, and the formation of protostars within them. It has, and continues to be, a valuable resource for astronomers!