The perils of star formation in the vicinity of massive stars

Some collaborators and I have recently had an interesting paper published in which we show that stars born in the vicinity of massive OB stars may be less likely to form planetary systems that stars born further away from such stars.

In our Galaxy stars form in a wide variety of environments, from small regions with only a handful of stars, up to massive star clusters and associations with millions of members. The larger regions are also home to tens to thousands of massive OB stars that emit immense amounts of energetic radiation that can affect nearby stars.

The OB association Cygnus OB2 (Credit: CXO).

One of the questions facing astronomers is whether stars born in the vicinity of multiple OB stars might grow up differently to stars born in regions devoid of such objects. In particular it has been suggested that the radiation from these massive OB stars could erode the disks of material that surround young stars.  These protoplanetary disks are thought to be in the process of forming planetary systems just like our Solar System, so its important we understand how they form and evolve.

The study, lead by my colleague Mario Guarcello, focusses on young stars in the OB association Cygnus OB2, a region home to thousands of massive and luminous OB stars, as well as many less massive stars like our Sun. In the paper they study the spatial distribution of stars with and without protoplanetary disks and find that stars nearer to OB stars are less likely to have a disk around them than stars further away from the OB stars (see figure to the right).

The fraction of stars with disks (y-axis) plotted
against the strength of ultraviolet radiation
from massive stars (x-axis). The fraction of stars
with disks is lower when the ultraviolet flux is
higher (Credit: Guarcello et al. 2016).

This suggests that the OB stars are somehow eroding or destroying the protoplanetary disks around stars in their vicinity, most likely due to the photo-evaporation of material in the disks by the harsh ultraviolet radiation that these stars emit.

This result is very important for our understanding of where planetary systems are forming in our galaxy and what factors are hindering this process. As we start to search for planetary systems in distant star clusters we may find that such systems are rarer, or perhaps have fewer planets in them, than those around stars that aren't in star clusters.

This may also tell us something about where our Sun and its Solar System formed. If protoplanetary disks are eroded in massive clusters and associations, then it is unlikely that our Sun formed in an environment such as this.

Planet-forming discs around young stars truncated by close encounters in Orion

The protoplanetary disk of HL Tau, as observed by the
ALMA Observatory. Discs like those would be continually
eroded by close encounters in dense star clusters like
the Orion Nebula Cluste (Credit: APOD)

Astronomers have for a long time suspected that the environment in which stars form could very strongly influence the formation of planetary systems. A recent paper by Simon Portegies Zwart at the Leiden Observatory shows this to be case and reports results of simulations that explore this effect. The simulations show that close encounters between stars in a dense cluster can truncate the protoplanetary discs around stars where planetary systems are thought to form. His simulations are able to reproduce the properties of protoplanetary discs in the nearby Orion Nebula Cluster, suggesting the stars and discs in this cluster have already felt the impact of their crowded environment. These interactions will not only lead to an erosion of the disc (leaving less material available to form planets) but also reduces the orbital radii at which planets can form, impacting the types of planetary system that might form.

Why are we interested in star clusters?

This blog is all about star clusters, which are pretty stunning and amazing astronomical objects, but some of you might be wondering why astronomers are so interested in them. So in this post I thought I'd give my Top 5 Reasons to Study Star Clusters! I hope you enjoy it!

The Orion Nebula Cluster, seen in X-rays and
optical light. By estimating the masses of the
young stars formed here we can study the
distribution of stellar masses that form
(Credit: Chandra X-ray Observatory)

1. Star formation. Perhaps the most important reason to study star clusters is because we believe the majority of stars form in groups or clusters and so by studying young star clusters we hope to learn something about how stars form. For example, by measuring the masses of all the stars in a cluster we can study the mass distribution of recently-formed stars (known as the initial mass function), which is one of the most important products of the star formation process.

Hubble Space Telescope image of an evaporating
protoplanetary disk (known as a proplyd) in the
Orion Nebula. The disk (dark silhouette in the
centre) is being eroded by radiation from a
nearby bright O-type star leading to the tail of
material stripped off(Credit: NASA/HST)

2. The impact of environment on star formation. Stars form in many different environments, from small groups of only a handful of stars, up to dense clusters with millions of stars and many thousands of luminous and massive OB stars. In dense clusters young stars are very close to each other, which can lead to close encounters that might disrupt binary systems or planetary systems. The bright OB stars that are present in the most massive clusters can also erode the disks around stars in which planets form, potentially hindering the creation of a full solar system like our own. Understanding how the environment that stars form in affects their final properties is therefore very important!

3. Stellar evolution. Just like humans, stars change as they age in many different ways, from subtle changes in their luminosity and slowing their rotation, to dramatic changes as they switch their source of nuclear fuel. To study these changes we need to know how old the stars are, but unfortunately its very difficult to measure how old individual stars are (we can't ask stars how old they are like we do with humans!). If you have a group of stars, however, you can often work out how old the group is by studying which stars have come to the ends of their lives and which haven't. This allows you to estimate the age of the cluster, and therefore all the stars in it. Once you know their ages you can study how the stars have evolved over time, an area of research known as stellar evolution.

The life cycle of a star like our Sun (upper row) and a more massive OB-type star (lower row).
Both types of star form in star forming regions and star clusters, but evolve through different
phases. By studying this process in star clusters with known ages, astronomers can
calculate how long this evolution takes (Image credit: SciOly.org)

4. Star clusters can be used to study star formation in distant galaxies. Its easy to study star formation in our own galaxy, the Milky Way, because we can observe stars forming deep within molecular clouds and the young stars that have recently formed. But in distant galaxies these things are too small and too faint to observe, so our understanding of star formation in other galaxies, whether it is different in any way, and how much star formation has been occurring, is limited. Star clusters however are bright and we can easily observe them in distant galaxies. Its also relatively simple to get a good estimate of their mass, the type of stars in them, and how old they are. This is really useful for astronomers because it means we can study not just the current star formation in these galaxies, but also star formation that occurred in the past. Astronomers call this the star formation history of a galaxy and its useful for understanding how galaxies evolve over cosmic time.

The Antennae Galaxies, two interacting galaxies with a rich and vibrant star formation history.
Astronomers have been able to study its star formation history by observing the many
star clusters (bright blue dots surrounded by red clouds) (Credit: Hubble Space Telescope)

The Jewel box Cluster (NGC 4755), one of many
clusters that are important for measuring distances
in astronomy! (Credit: APOD)

5. Star clusters are an important step on the cosmic distance ladder. In actual fact, they're two steps! The first step is a 'local' step on the cosmic distance ladder, and it comes from a process known as the moving cluster method, which is essentially a perspective effect whereby if you know the direction that all the stars in a cluster are moving you can estimate how far away it is. The second step is a much more 'distant' step on the ladder, which uses the luminosity of globular clusters to estimate the distance of the galaxy that they're in. The method stems from the assumption that the brightness globular cluster in a galaxy usually has the same luminosity as the brightest globular cluster in another galaxy. Based on this, if you can measure how bright the globular clusters in a galaxy are, you can estimate how far away the galaxy is.

There are many other reasons to study star clusters, but these are some of the most important and wide-ranging, spanning the formation of planetary systems to the size of the Universe!

So next time you hear about star clusters or new research into our understanding of these amazing objects, think about all the different scientific topics that might be influenced by those new results!

Star birth and the Sea Serpent

What do sea serpents have to do with star formation I hear you ask! Well normally the two may not be connected, but this sea serpent is no ordinary snake, it is the giant constellation of Hydra, otherwise known as the Sea Serpent! Within this constellation lies a very important young star known as TW Hydrae, which has the honour of being the closest T-Tauri star to the Sun.

T-Tauri stars, as I've discussed before, are young stars, named after the prototypical example T Tauri. They are stars which have almost completely formed but are still accreting some material from their surroundings, which can cause them to glow brightly. This accretion process is not fully understood and so astronomers try to study as many different accreting stars as possible so that they can better understand how this is happening and how the accretion is affecting the star.

Artists impression of the TW Hydrae star
and its protoplanetary disk (Credit: NASA)

TW Hydrae is particularly important because it is the closest T-Tauri star at a distance of only 176 light years, and therefore it is the easiest such object to study. It was first recognised as a young star by American astronomer (and later astronaut) Karl Gorden Henize, who noted extreme H-alpha emission, typical of strongly accreting objects, in 1976.

The isolation of the star, not near any other T-Tauri stars or known star forming regions, suggested to some astronomers that it might not be a truly young star. However thanks to further observations of the star a few years later it was shown to be a bona fide and fully accreting young T-Tauri star, despite its apparent isolation.

The star itself is similar to our Sun, a little less massive and therefore a little redder, but much younger. Current estimates put its age at about 5-10 million years old, considerably younger than the 4.6 billion year old Sun that we orbit.

Fortunately for us of course the Sun is not a young star, because young stars like TW Hydrae can be very volatile objects. Young stars are surrounded by a disk of gas and dust known as a protoplanetary disk. These disks are created as material falls towards the star and gathers in a disk around it, due to a process known as the conservation of angular momentum (which basically means that things that spiral in towards a star like to keep spiralling, or at least orbiting the star and this can sometimes stop the material from falling onto the star).

Material from this disk is occasionally accreted onto the star, channeled along magnetic field lines before pummelling onto the star's surface. When this material hits the stellar surface it is heated to incredibly high temperatures, approximately 3 million degrees, which causes the star to briefly shine brightly. You don't want to be near such stars when they're accreting!

The stars and motions of the TW Hydrae association (shown in red and labelled "TW Hya" and with new members shown in black) relative to other nearby OB associations (Credit: Murphy et al. 2015).

Recently astronomers have uncovered other low-mass stars in the vicinity of TW Hydrae, creating a small group of about 20-30 stars known as the TW Hydrae association. These stars are all very young and share a common motion through our Galaxy, suggesting that they probably formed together. This discovery will be useful for astronomers looking for other young stars to study, as well as for studying how stars form in groups such as these. And importantly, TW Hydrae isn't alone any more!