The perils of star formation in the vicinity of massive stars

Some collaborators and I have recently had an interesting paper published in which we show that stars born in the vicinity of massive OB stars may be less likely to form planetary systems that stars born further away from such stars.

In our Galaxy stars form in a wide variety of environments, from small regions with only a handful of stars, up to massive star clusters and associations with millions of members. The larger regions are also home to tens to thousands of massive OB stars that emit immense amounts of energetic radiation that can affect nearby stars.

The OB association Cygnus OB2 (Credit: CXO).

One of the questions facing astronomers is whether stars born in the vicinity of multiple OB stars might grow up differently to stars born in regions devoid of such objects. In particular it has been suggested that the radiation from these massive OB stars could erode the disks of material that surround young stars.  These protoplanetary disks are thought to be in the process of forming planetary systems just like our Solar System, so its important we understand how they form and evolve.

The study, lead by my colleague Mario Guarcello, focusses on young stars in the OB association Cygnus OB2, a region home to thousands of massive and luminous OB stars, as well as many less massive stars like our Sun. In the paper they study the spatial distribution of stars with and without protoplanetary disks and find that stars nearer to OB stars are less likely to have a disk around them than stars further away from the OB stars (see figure to the right).

The fraction of stars with disks (y-axis) plotted
against the strength of ultraviolet radiation
from massive stars (x-axis). The fraction of stars
with disks is lower when the ultraviolet flux is
higher (Credit: Guarcello et al. 2016).

This suggests that the OB stars are somehow eroding or destroying the protoplanetary disks around stars in their vicinity, most likely due to the photo-evaporation of material in the disks by the harsh ultraviolet radiation that these stars emit.

This result is very important for our understanding of where planetary systems are forming in our galaxy and what factors are hindering this process. As we start to search for planetary systems in distant star clusters we may find that such systems are rarer, or perhaps have fewer planets in them, than those around stars that aren't in star clusters.

This may also tell us something about where our Sun and its Solar System formed. If protoplanetary disks are eroded in massive clusters and associations, then it is unlikely that our Sun formed in an environment such as this.

The massive stars of Cygnus OB2

A couple of weeks ago I talked about an OB association known as Cygnus OB2, one of the largest groups of young stars in our galaxy, and an exciting location to study star formation on the grandest scales. This week I want to tell you about some research I recently carried out to better understand this region, research which has recently been published.

The Cygnus OB2 association, as seen though a combination of
X-ray (blue), optical (yellow) and infrared (red) light
(Credit: Chandra X-ray Observatory)

There has been a lot of work carried out recently by many other astronomers to understand some of the really massive stars in Cygnus OB2, which are all very interesting objects, many of which are unique and can tell us exciting things about how massive stars live their short and turbulent lives. Thanks to this work we're now in a position to put all this information together and use it to better understand the entire group of stars as a whole, and that's what I did!

I was able to gather information about 169 massive stars in Cygnus OB2, including some stars as massive as 100 times the mass of our Sun. For each of these stars I was able to determine their mass and age, by comparing their measured properties with the predictions from models of how massive stars evolve throughout their lives. One of the main advances in astronomy over the last few decades has been the development of models that describe not just how stars change throughout their lives, but how they appear during this time. These models, known as stellar evolution models, allow astronomers to estimate how old and how massive the stars that they see are.

The positions of massive stars (red, green and yellow dots) across the Cygnus region, shown against a black and white infrared image of the region. The white circle denotes the area covered by Cygnus OB2 and studied in my paper
(Credit: Nick Wright)

With this information we were able to determine the approximate ages of all the massive stars, allowing us to determine what's known as the star formation history of the region. The star formation history tells us when all the stars formed, and that's important to know if we want to understand how massive OB associations like this formed.

The simple view would be that all the stars formed at the same, or at least very similar, times. This is what's known as instantaneous star formation, or star-burst, because all the star formation occurs in a quick burst when the conditions in the molecular cloud become right for star formation.

The centre of the Cygnus OB2 association - or is it multiple associations?
(Credit: Nick Wright)

However that wasn't what we found. Instead we found that the ages of the stars were spread out over quite a long time period, almost 10 million years. That's a long period of time for star formation, because most astronomers think star formation occurs quickly, within only 1-2 million years or less. But here we're seeing that the star formation didn't happen all at once but was spread out, happening almost constantly for 10 million years.

What does this mean? Is the star formation that has occurred here any different from star formation taking place elsewhere? Probably not. What probably happened here is that the star formation didn't just take place over a long period of time, but probably also took place over a large area of space, almost like multiple small star formation events! These individual star formation events have since merged and combined so that we see them now as this large and homogeneous group of young stars.

It's a theory anyway. One of the great joys of science is discovering something you didn't expect to find, thinking of a new theory to describe what you saw, and then testing your theory. Science is not set in stone but is continually evolving with new theories being proposed, and existing theories being tested, and then refined or discarded. We call this the scientific method, and it underpins all of science.

You can read the full paper here if you're interested to learn more.

Where the wild things are: Cygnus OB2

This week I want to tell you about one of my favourite astronomical objects, and one which I have spent many years studying, the Cygnus OB2 association.

Cygnus OB2 is a loose group of young stars known as an association, a sort of less-dense version of a star cluster. As the name would suggest, the Cygnus OB2 association is the 2nd OB association catalogued in the constellation of Cygnus. This constellation lies very prominently in the plane of our galaxy where the majority of stars and nearly all young stars in our galaxy are found.

The Milky Way, showing the constellation of Cygnus and the position of the Cygnus OB2 association
(Original image credit: Axel Mellinger)

From the image above you wouldn't believe anything particularly exciting was happening in Cygnus, as the region appears mostly dark, particularly around Cygnus OB2 itself. The reason for this is that between us and Cygnus OB2 there is a vast cloud of obscuring dust that absorbs the majority of starlight emitted by the association, hiding it from us. This cloud of dust is sometimes referred to as the Cygnus Rift or the Great Rift, and can be seen extending across much of the Galactic Plane, as the above image shows.

Optical photons are readily absorbed by dust particles, but infrared photons are less susceptible to this problem and can penetrate these obscuring dust clouds. An infrared view of the Galactic Plane, such as that shown below thanks to Japan's Akari satellite, reveals the prominent sites of star-formation activity in our galaxy, radiating brightly thanks to the many young stars forming within them.

The Milky Way in infrared light, as seen by the Akari satellite, with major infrared-bright regions labelled
(Credit: ESA)

The brightest and most prominent of all these star forming regions is probably the Cygnus region, despite it being more distant than many of the other star forming regions shown on this image. This brightness is testament to the intense amount of star formation that has, and still is occurring in this region. In fact when this region was first studied at radio wavelengths the bright structure was so prominent as to be marked with an 'X', hence leading to the name of Cygnus X for the whole star forming complex.

Detailed infrared view of the Cygnus X region, with
Cygnus OB2 in the centre (Credit: NASA)

Zooming into this image we can begin to see some of the amazing structures present within the Cygnus X giant molecular cloud. Vast clouds of gas and dust can be seen collapsing to form young stars, while huge pillars are constantly being sculpted and eroded by the recently-formed stars. This is a place where star formation takes place at the extremes!

Right in the centre of the Cygnus X giant molecular cloud is the Cygnus OB2 association, a massive group of young stars, as populous as some of the most massive young star clusters in our galaxy, yet nowhere near as compact.

The diffuseness of Cygnus OB2, coupled with the obscuring dust clouds, led to it being maligned for many decades. Only in the last 15 years, thanks to the revolutions in infrared and X-ray astronomy, have researchers been able to penetrate the extinction and uncover the thousands of massive, young stars in this huge OB association, including some of the most massive and luminous stars known!

As I said at the beginning of this post, Cygnus OB2 is a region I have studied for many years, hoping to better understand its origins and its content, and therefore to appreciate its role in the continual evolution of our galaxy. Next week I hope to share some exciting news and discoveries about Cygnus OB2 that we will be publishing very soon, so stay tuned!